Oatmeal Cream Pies
For the cookies:
Directions:
Preheat oven to 350°F and adjust rack to middle position. Place butter, muscovado and whole cane sugar in the bowl of a standing mixer. Using beater attachment, beat butter and sugars on medium speed until combined, about 1 minute. With mixer on low, add egg and vanilla. Stir together flours, oats, baking soda, sea salt, and cinnamon. Turn mixer on low and slowly add flour mixture to butter mixture until incorporated.
Scoop dough using a 1 1/2-inch cookie scoop (if you don’t have this kind of scoop you can scoop it out with a spoon, just try and scoop the balls evenly) and put on a baking sheet lined with parchment paper. Bake for 11 minutes. Cool to room temperature.
For the Filling:
2 eggs
1/2 cup organic whole cane sugar or sucanat
1 teaspoons vanilla
pinch of salt
2 sticks butter, softened, each stick cut into tablespoons
Directions:
In the bowl of a standing mixer whisk together, eggs, whole cane sugar, vanilla and pinch of salt. Set bowl over pot of simmering water. Whisk constantly until the mixture reaches 160 degrees, about 5 minutes. Beat egg mixture on medium-high with whisk attachment until light and billowy, about 5 minutes. Reduce the speed to medium and add butter one tablespoon at a time. When all of the butter is added it might look curdled, but keep mixing. Turn mixer on high and beat for 1 minute until light and fluffy.
To assemble cookies: Spoon buttercream into a pastry bag with a large tip attached. (If you don’t have a pastry bag, simply spoon the buttercream into a ziploc bag and snip one corner off of the bag.) Pipe about 2 tablespoons buttercream onto half of the cookies. Top the frosted cookies with another cookie to create a sandwich.
Posts may contain affiliate links. If you purchase a product through an affiliate link, your costs will be the same but Deliciously Organic will receive a small commission. This helps cover some of the costs for this site. We appreciate your support!
















{ 25 comments… read them below or add one }
Would honey be substitutable? (I have honey in my pantry…)
These look amazing. These would make our household very happy!
Those cream pies look fantastic!! A fabulous treat!
Just found your blog on tastespotting, wonderful post.I'm going to bookmark this recipe!
Love it! And love your blog!
im impressed, always good to see all organic recipes! love your blog!
You have outdone yourself with these. They look creamy & crumbly good.
This past weekend I had a fantastic Oatmeal Cream Pie from Whole Foods and I've been thinking about it ever since. The one I had was maple flavored. Could the rapadura in the filling be replaced with maple syrup as the sweetener or would that mess up the texture of the buttercream? Also, could maple syrup work in the cookie recipe instead of vanilla or would you have to adjust the sweetner quantity as well?
Elizabeth, in what state was the Whole Foods located that you got the maple cream pie at? I used to love them as a kid but they stopped making them in Massachusetts stores about 6 years ago. I still crave them to this day.
Did you ever get a reply to this? I too LOVE the ones from whole foods and likewise can’t find them in MA. I came across this as I finally decided to try to hunt down th eir recipe. Eager to give this a try-although curious about the maple.
She didn’t reply. Sorry!
What beautiful "pies." I know what I'll be doing this weekend…making my family happy!Thanks for the great recipe.jessyburke88@gmail.com
These look fantastic! I'm very excited to try them!
Ann: I haven't tried them with honey, but I don't think it would be a good substitute. If honey was used I'm afraid the cookies would run all over the pan…they'd still taste great though! Elizabeth: You could try substituting 1/2 of the whole cane sugar with maple syrup in the buttercream recipe and see how it does. For the cookie dough, I'd stick with the sugars listed b/c syrup might make the cookies run all over the pan. Please let me know how they turn out if you make them!
goodness gracious.
I LOVED oatmeal cream pies when i was little. Thanks for bringing back great memories! I can't wait to make these.
Wow! I love this-wish I was at your house on this fine day that these were baked. This is truly a great recreation of something so many people crave…
These oatmeal sandwiches look fabulous for a snack. Thank you for a delicious recipe.
There's nothing as tasty as a batch of memories. I'm like that with a lot of foods…and I think they taste so much better than normal food when it conjurs up sweet days of the past.-Gail
This looks yummy. I will due this recipe for sure.Have a great day.
Why can't I be your neighbor??
What a great idea! The oatmeal cream pies look delicious, and I can't wait to see how you recreate the other classic Little Debbie snacks!
Made these last weekend! By far the best oatmeal cookie I've ever had. The filling was a little too buttery for me. I think next time I'll use just a little less butter and a little more sugar and vanilla. Overall, AWESOME.
These look great! Can they be frozen to keep?
The cookies (without the filling) can be frozen in an airtight container for up to 3 months. You could then thaw and put in the filling.
{ 2 trackbacks }